Appearances: S1: Hug, Zero (mentioned)
Bio: A former doctor, Toby was an "on-call specialist," attending to patients, no questions asked. In '99, he'd stitched up Lex Luthor after Lex had gotten stabbed in the shoulder by Jude Royce at Club Zero. Lex had been referred to him by Sam Phelan, a rogue cop who'd been trying to help cover up Lex's involvement in Jude's death. In early 2002, Lex had asked him to stitch up Kyle Tippet, who was then a fugitive from the law. In both instances, Lex had paid Toby in liquor.
Played By: R. Nelson Brown