Appearances: S1: Zero (flashback)
Family: brother, Roy Rothman
Bio: Amanda Rothman was an old friend of Lex Luthor, and the former fiancée of the late Jude Royce. In 1999, while Jude was supposed to have been away on business, Lex had taken Amanda to Club Zero in Metropolis, where they had found Jude surrounded by women. Hurt by his lies and infidelity, Amanda had thrown her engagement ring at Jude, effectively ending their relationship. Accusing Lex of deliberately bringing Amanda to the club, Jude had attacked, stabbing Lex in the shoulder. The club's bouncer, Max Kasitch, had quickly gotten involved, brandishing a gun. However, in the scuffle, he'd dropped the gun, and Amanda had picked it up, fatally shooting Jude. To protect Amanda, Lex had later told rogue cop, Sam Phelan, that he and Max had struggled for the gun and it had gone off, killing Jude. For his part of the cover-up, Phelan had written in his report that Max alone had shot Jude, before receiving a big payoff from Lex's father Lionel. Amanda had nonetheless felt guilt for killing Jude, and had eventually taken her own life. After Amanda's brother Roy had stumbled upon a Jude lookalike working in a diner, Roy had gotten the idea to use the lookalike to torment Lex into confessing, believing Lex had been responsible for Jude's death and that Amanda had committed suicide because she'd been devastated at the loss of her fiancé.
Portrayed By: Jud Tylor